Trading Journal Templates: How to Review Good & Bad Trades Like a Pro

Most traders journal only their losing trades.

Some journal their winning trades.

Few journal both - and almost no one journals them correctly.

The truth is:

• A bad trade doesn’t automatically mean a mistake.
• A good trade doesn’t automatically mean good process.
• A winning trade can be a terrible decision.
• A losing trade can be a perfect execution.

If you don’t review properly, you reinforce the wrong habits and weaken the right ones.

This section shows you how to:

• Break down every trade with precision
• Separate skill from luck
• Identify structural issues in your execution
• Understand pattern recognition flaws
• Improve system alignment
• Strengthen confidence through evidence
• Build your unconscious competence

When done correctly, trade reviews become your fastest path to mastery - much faster than taking more trades.

To deepen your foundation, revisit:

• Execution Psychology
• Managing Losses & Winning Big
• The Confirmation Matrix
• What Is an Order Block?

These concepts support the analytical layers of the templates below.

Let’s get into the structure.

1. The Four Pillars of a Proper Trade Review

Every trade - win or loss - must be reviewed through these four pillars:

A. System Quality

Did the trade follow your strategy rules?

B. Execution Quality

Did you enter and manage correctly?

C. Behavioral Quality

What was your emotional and cognitive state?

D. Market Condition Fit

Was the environment favorable for this kind of setup?

When a trade goes wrong, the cause is always one of these four pillars.

Your template will break this down systematically.

2. The Perfect Trade Review Format (Used by Professional Traders)

Here is the template:

Trade Review Template (Universal)

1. Trade Summary (What Happened?)

• Pair / Asset
• Session
• Setup type
• Entry reason
• Stop-loss location
• Target(s)
• Result (+R or –R)

This is not analysis - it is documentation.

2. System Checklist (Was It a Valid Setup?)

Rate each item Yes / No / Partial:

• HTF bias aligned?
• Liquidity sweep taken?
• MSS/BOS confirmed?
• Valid POI?
• FVG present or mitigation?
• Timing aligned (London/NY)?
• Market condition favorable?

If any critical confirmation is missing - the setup is invalid.

3. Execution Review (Did You Execute Well?)

Answer with Clean / Imperfect / Poor:

• Entry timing
• SL placement
• TP execution
• Risk sizing
• Trade management
• Patience before entry
• No FOMO impulses

This section revealed to thousands of traders that execution is often the real problem, not the system.

4. Emotional Review (What Were You Feeling?)

Rate emotions before and after:

Before:

• Confidence
• Clarity
• FOMO
• Fear
• Stress

After:

• Satisfaction
• Regret
• Emotional drift

By comparing before/after, you reveal emotional shifts that influence future trades.

5. Bias Identification (Which Bias Was Active?)

Possible biases:

• Recency bias
• Revenge bias
• Overconfidence
• Fear of missing out
• Confirmation bias
• Illusion of control
• Outcome bias

Bias detection is critical - it prevents your mental model from degrading over time.

6. Market Condition Assessment (Was This the Right Environment?)

Tag conditions:

• Trending / Choppy
• High volatility / Low volatility
• HTF premium / discount
• Pre-news / post-news
• Liquidity-rich / liquidity-dry

You’ll quickly learn:

Half of losing trades come from trading in the wrong conditions.

7. What Went Right / What Went Wrong

Simple but powerful:

What I did well:

Focus on repeatable skills.

What I did poorly:

Focus on mistakes you can eliminate.

8. Lesson Reinforcement (What Changes Next?)

• One rule to internalize
• One behavior to reduce
• One condition filter to add
• One confirmation to be stricter with

This creates forward momentum, not just reflection.

9. Screenshot Markups

Attach:

• Entry screenshot
• HTF context
• LTF execution
• Mistake highlights
• Lessons written on the image

This forms a powerful visual memory bank.

3. Good Trade Review - How to Reinforce Skilled Behavior

A “good trade” is NOT defined by profit.

A good trade is defined by:

• Following rules
• Executing cleanly
• Managing emotions
• Respecting market structure
• Letting the system play out
• Taking the correct risk
• Accepting the outcome

When reviewing winning trades:

Focus on the process, not the profit.

Ask:

• Why did this setup work?
• Which confirmations were strongest?
• Did the market reward your process?
• Could you scale this setup in future?
• Did you stay calm throughout?
• Did you exit at a logical location?
• Did your behavior match your identity as a trader?

Good trade reviews hard-wire the processes that create consistency.

Without this, you lose the opportunity to strengthen your strengths.

4. Bad Trade Review - How to Extract Gold From Losses

A bad trade review must answer one question:

“Was this a bad trade or a valid loss?”

A Valid Loss

• Setup was clean
• Conditions aligned
• Rules followed
• SL placed correctly
• Market simply didn’t follow through

Valid losses must be embraced - they build resilience and trust in your edge.

A Bad Trade

Bad trades fall into categories:

System Error:

Rule flaw or strategy weakness.

Execution Error:

Mistimed entry, bad SL, poor TP.

Behavior Error:

FOMO, fear, revenge, hesitation.

Environment Error:

Trading when tired, distracted, stressed.

These must be isolated and removed systematically.

5. The “5 Why’s” Root Cause Analysis (Elite-Level Learning)

Used by engineers, now applied to trading.

Example:

Why did I lose this trade?

Because price reversed immediately.

Why?

Because I entered before liquidity sweep.

Why?

Because I feared missing the move.

Why?

Because I previously missed a winning setup.

Why?

Because I haven’t accepted that not every move is mine.

This transforms emotional mistakes into actionable clarity.

6. The Journal of Patterns - Where Mastery Emerges

After 20–50 reviews, patterns begin appearing:

• Certain setups win consistently
• Certain confirmations are mandatory
• Certain conditions kill performance
• Certain behaviors cause repeated errors
• Certain times of day perform best
• Certain emotional states lead to disaster
• Certain rule violations cost the most money

This is where your journal becomes powerful:

You stop guessing - and start knowing.

That is the beginning of professionalism.

Real-Life Analogy - Recording Your Sparring Sessions

Boxers record their sparring sessions to study:

• Timing
• Footwork
• Mistakes
• Defensive gaps
• Strong combinations
• Fatigue points

Not because they love watching themselves lose rounds…

but because every recording contains patterns.

Your trade review plays the same role.

Each review carries hidden patterns - ones that make or break your future performance.

Final Thoughts

Your trades are not just entries and exits - they are data points revealing who you are as a trader.

A proper trade review template turns every outcome into:

• clarity
• structure
• self-awareness
• skill growth
• emotional stability
• system refinement

The fastest traders to reach consistency aren’t the most talented -

they are the ones who review the deepest.

This is your edge.

Use it.

FAQs

1. How long should a trade review take?

5–10 minutes for regular trades.

15–20 minutes for trades that reveal new patterns.

2. Should I review every trade?

Yes - until mastery.

After that, review only high-impact trades.

3. What if the trade was pure luck?

Document it.

Luck disguises bad habits.

4. Should I track screenshots?

Absolutely.

Visual memory accelerates pattern recognition.

.Start Trading Live!

• Trade forex, indices, gold, and more
• Access ACY, MT4, MT5, & Copy Trading Platforms

It’s time to go from theory to execution!

Create an Account. Start Your Live Trading Now!

Check Out My Contents:

Beginners Path

• Learn Trading From Scratch: Clean, Simple, Zero-Noise
• Introduction to Trading: What Beginners Must Understand
• Choosing Your Trading Market: Forex, Gold, or Indices
• Beginner Trading Strategy: How to Choose One Setup and Commit
• Minimalist Trading Indicators: The Only Tools Beginners Need
• Master Candlestick Entries: Reading Price Action at Key Levels
• Backtesting for Traders: How to Build Skill Fast
• Trading Risk Management: The Real Edge Behind Consistency
• Trading Psychology: How to Control Yourself in the Markets
• Daily Trading Routine: Build Consistency and Discipline Fast
• Scenario Planning: Expect Both Sides
• Beginner Trading Master Guide 2025: The Complete Roadmap to Consistency

Strategies That You Can Use

Looking for step-by-step approaches you can plug straight into the charts? Start here:

• How To Trade & Scalp Indices at the Open Using Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• How to Trade Breakouts Effectively in Day Trading with Smart Money Concepts
• Complete Step-by-Step Guide to Day Trading Gold (XAU/USD) with Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• The Power of Multi-Timeframe Analysis in Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• Forex Trading Strategy for Beginners
• Mastering Candlestick Pattern Analysis with the SMC Strategy for Day Trading
• How to Use Fibonacci to Set Targets & Stops (Complete Guide)
• RSI Divergence Trading Strategy for Gold: How to Identify and Trade Trend Reversals
• Stochastics Trading Secrets: How to Time Entries in Trending Markets using Stochastics
• Gold Trading Stochastics Strategy: How to Trade Gold with 2R - 3R Targets
• RSI Hidden Divergence Explained: How to Spot Trend Continuations Like a Pro
• Moving Averages Trading Strategy Playbook
• Mastering Fibonacci Trading Psychology - Trusting the Levels, Managing the Mind
• Mastering Price Action at Key Levels - How to Spot, Trade, and Win at the Most Crucial Zones
• Mastering Retests: How to Enter with Confirmation After a Breakout

Indicators / Tools for Trading

Sharpen your edge with proven tools and frameworks:

• The Ultimate Guide to Risk Management in Trading - A Complete Compilation for 2025
• Moving Averages Trading Strategy Playbook
• How to Think Like a Price Action Trader
• Mastering Fibonacci Trading Psychology - Trusting the Levels, Managing the Mind

How To Trade News

News moves markets fast. Learn how to keep pace with SMC-based playbooks:

• Why Smart Money Concepts Work in News-Driven Markets - CPI, NFP, and More
• How to Trade NFP Using Smart Money Concepts (SMC) - A Proven Strategy for Forex Traders
• How to Trade CPI Like Smart Money - A Step-by-Step Guide Using SMC
• Learn to Trade News by Backtesting it with Forex Tester

Learn How to Trade US Indices

From NASDAQ opens to DAX trends, here’s how to approach indices like a pro:

• How to Start Trading Indices and Get into the Stock Market with Low Capital (2025 Guide)
• Best Indices to Trade for Day Traders | NASDAQ, S&P 500, DAX + Best Times to Trade Them
• How To Trade & Scalp Indices at the Open Using Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• NAS100 - How to Trade the Nasdaq Like a Pro (Smart Money Edition)

How to Start Trading Gold

Gold remains one of the most traded assets - here’s how to approach it with confidence:

• How to Swing Trade Gold (XAU/USD) Using Smart Money Concepts: A Simple Guide for Traders
• Complete Step-by-Step Guide to Day Trading Gold (XAU/USD) with Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• The Ultimate Guide to Backtesting and Trading Gold (XAU/USD) Using Smart Money Concepts (SMC)
• Why Gold Remains the Ultimate Security in a Shifting World
• How to Exit & Take Profits in Trading Gold Like a Pro: Using RSI, Range Breakdowns, and MAs as Your Confluence
• Backtest Gold using Forex Tester Online

How to Trade Japanese Candlesticks

Candlesticks are the building blocks of price action. Master the most powerful ones:

• Mastering the Top Japanese Candlesticks: The Top 5 Candlesticks To Trade + Top SMC Candlestick Pattern
• How to Trade Candlestick Patterns with High Probability: A Complete Guide for Beginners
• The Top Japanese Candlestick Guide: What is an Engulfing Pattern and How to Trade It?
• Piercing Pattern Candlestick Explained: How to Trade It - Step-By-Step Guide
• Morning & Evening Star Candlestick Patterns - How to Trade Market Reversals with Confidence

How to Start Day Trading

Ready to go intraday? Here’s how to build consistency step by step:

• 5 Steps to Start Day Trading: A Strategic Guide for Beginners
• 8 Steps How to Start Forex Day Trading in 2025: A Beginner’s Step-by-Step Guide
• 3 Steps to Build a Trading Routine for Consistency and Discipline - Day Trading Edition
• The Ultimate Guide to Understanding Market Trends and Price Action
• Trading with Momentum: The Best Trading Session to Trade Forex, Gold and Indices

Swing Trading 101

• Introduction to Swing Trading
• The Market Basics for Swing Trading
• Core Principles of Swing Trading
• The Technical Foundations Every Swing Trader Must Master
• Swing Trader’s Toolkit: Multi-Timeframe & Institutional Confluence
• The Psychology of Risk Management in Swing Trading
• Swing Trading Concepts To Know In Trading with Smart Money Concepts
• Becoming a Consistent Swing Trader: Trading Structure & Scaling Strategy

Learn how to navigate yourself in times of turmoil

Markets swing between calm and chaos. Learn to read risk-on vs risk-off like a pro:

• How to Identify Risk-On and Risk-Off Market Sentiment: A Complete Trader’s Guide
• How to Trade Risk-On and Risk-Off Sentiment - With Technical Confirmation
• The Ultimate Guide to Understanding Market Trends and Price Action
• Metals in Risk-On and Risk-Off Environments: How Sentiment Moves Gold and Commodities

Want to learn how to trade like the Smart Money?

Step inside the playbook of institutional traders with SMC concepts explained:

• Why Smart Money Concepts Work: The Truth Behind Liquidity and Price Action
• Mastering the Market with Smart Money Concepts: 5 Strategic Approaches
• Understanding Liquidity Sweep: How Smart Money Trades Liquidity Zones in Forex, Gold, US Indices
• The SMC Playbook Series Part 1: What Moves the Markets? Key Drivers Behind Forex, Gold & Stock Indices
• The SMC Playbook Series Part 2: How to Spot Liquidity Pools in Trading - Internal vs External Liquidity Explained
• Fair Value Gaps Explained: How Smart Money Leaves Footprints in the Market
• Accumulation, Manipulation, Distribution: The Hidden Cycle That Runs Every Market
• Institutional Order Flow - Reading the Market Through the Eyes of the Big Players
• London Session Trading Secrets: How Smart Money Sets the High & Low of the Day
• Mastering the New York Session - Smart Money Concepts Guide
• Anatomy of a Perfect Execution: How SMC Traders Trade with Precision
• Step-by-Step Trading Confirmation Guide for Precise Execution
• Execution Psychology: Turning Hesitation into Confidence
• What Is an Order Block? The Institutional Footprint Explained
• Anatomy of a Valid Order Block in Smart Money Concepts
• How to Draw Order Blocks Accurately - Day Trading Style
• Order Blocks and AMD Market Structure (Smart Money Concepts)
• The Confirmation Model: OB + FVG + Liquidity Sweep (Smart Money Concepts)

Master the World’s Most Popular Forex Pairs

Forex pairs aren’t created equal - some are stable, some are volatile, others tied to commodities or sessions.

• The Top 5 All-Time Best Forex Pairs to Trade
• Top Forex Pairs Beyond the Big Five
• EUR/USD: The King of Forex
• USD/JPY: The Fast Mover
• GBP/USD: The Volatile Cable
• AUD/USD: The Commodity Currency
• USD/CAD: The Oil-Backed Pair
• GBP/JPY: How to Trade The Beast
• Asian & London Session Secrets
• Mastering the New York Session

Metals Trading

• Metals Trading: Why Gold and Metals Are Rising Again
• Silver Trading: The Underdog with Dual Identity
• Gold vs Silver: Institutional Demand Breakdown Explained
• How to Day Trade Silver Like a Pro: Smart Money Tactics for XAG/USD
• Platinum & Palladium: The Quiet Power Duo of Industrial Metals
• How to Trade Metals with SMC and Fundamentals - Gold Trading Strategy
• Metals in Risk-On and Risk-Off Environments: How Sentiment Moves Gold and Commodities
• Future of Metals Market: Gold Forecast 2026 & Long-Term Commodities Outlook

Stop Hunting 101

If you’ve ever been stopped out right before the market reverses - this is why:

• Stop Hunting 101: How Swing Highs and Lows Become Liquidity Traps
• Outsmarting Stop Hunts: The Psychology Behind the Trap
• How to Lessen Risk From Stop Hunts in Trading
• How Stop Hunts Trigger Revenge Trading - Breaking the Pain Cycle
• How to Accept Stop Hunts Without Losing Discipline - Shifting From Frustration to Focus

Trading Psychology

Mindset is the deciding factor between growth and blowups. Explore these essentials:

• The Mental Game of Execution - Debunking the Common Trading Psychology
• Managing Trading Losses: Why You Can Be Wrong and Still Win Big in Trading
• The Hidden Threat in Trading: How Performance Anxiety Sabotages Your Edge
• Why 90% of Retail Traders Fail Even with Profitable Trading Strategies
• Top 10 Habits Profitable Traders Follow Daily to Stay Consistent
• Top 10 Trading Rules of the Most Successful Traders
• Top 10 Ways to Prevent Emotional Trading and Stay Disciplined in the Markets
• Why Most Traders Fail - Trading Psychology & The Hidden Mental Game
• Emotional Awareness in Trading - Naming Your Triggers
• Discipline vs. Impulse in Trading - Step-by Step Guide How to Build Control
• Trading Journal & Reflection - The Trader’s Mirror
• Overcoming FOMO & Revenge Trading in Forex - Why Patience Pays
• Risk of Ruin in Trading - Respect the Math of Survival
• Identity-Based Trading: Become Your Trading System for Consistency
• Trading Psychology: Aligning Emotions with Your System
• Mastering Fear in Trading: Turn Doubt into a Protective Signal
• Mastering Greed in Trading: Turn Ambition into Controlled Growth
• Mastering Boredom in Trading: From Restless Clicking to Patient Precision
• Mastering Doubt in Trading: Building Confidence Through Backtesting and Pattern Recognition
• Mastering Impatience in Trading: Turn Patience Into Profit
• Mastering Frustration in Trading: Turning Losses Into Lessons
• Mastering Hope in Trading: Replacing Denial With Discipline
• When to Quit on Trading - Read This!
• The Math of Compounding in Trading
• Why Daily Wins Matter More Than Big Wins
• Scaling in Trading: When & How to Increase Lot Sizes
• Why Patience in Trading Fuels the Compounding Growth
• Step-by-Step Guide on How to Manage Losses for Compounding Growth
• The Daily Habits of Profitable Traders: Building Your Compounding Routine
• Trading Edge: Definition, Misconceptions & Casino Analogy
• Finding Your Edge: From Chaos to Clarity
• Proving Your Edge: Backtesting Without Bias
• Forward Testing in Trading: How to Prove Your Edge Live
• Measuring Your Edge: Metrics That Matter
• Refining Your Edge: Iteration Without Overfitting
• The EDGE Framework: Knowing When and How to Evolve as a Trader
• Scaling Your Edge: From Small Account to Consistency
• Trading in the Zone: Execution Through Habit and Structure
• Trading in the Zone: Thinking in Probabilities
• The Inner War: Fear, Greed, and the Illusion of Control
• Detachment Discipline in Trading: How to Let Go of the Need to Be Right
• Trading Hack: Why You Keep Breaking Your Own Rules (And How to Stop)
• Trading Mindset Mastery: Building Confidence Through Data
• Flow State Trading: Entering the Zone Through Structure
• Cognitive Traps in Trading: Overconfidence, Recency Bias & Revenge Trades
• The Psychology of Risk in Trading: Fear of Loss vs Fear of Missing Out
• Self-Trust in Trading – Building Confidence from Repetition, Not Just Results
• The Zen of Trading: Becoming the Observer, Not the Reactor
• The Market Is Always Right: Why You Must Adapt, Not Demand
• The Three Stages to Becoming a Consistent Trader
• The Enemy Within: Limiting Beliefs and Emotional Conflict in Trading
• Self-Discipline in Trading: A Skill, Not a Personality Trait
• Mental Energy Management in Trading: Controlling Impulse, Stress, and Overwhelm
• Creating the Disciplined Trader Identity
• The Disciplined Trader: The Complete Blueprint for Consistency

Market Drivers

• Central Banks and Interest Rates: How They Move Your Trades
• Inflation & Economic Data: CPI Trading Strategy and PPI Indicator Guide
• Geopolitical Risks & Safe Havens in Trading (Gold, USD, JPY, CHF)
• Jobs, Growth & Recession Fears: NFP, GDP & Unemployment in Trading
• Commodities & Global Trade: Oil, Gold, and Forex Explained
• Market Correlations & Intermarket Analysis for Traders

Risk Management

The real edge in trading isn’t strategy - it’s how you protect your capital:

• Mastering Risk Management: Stop Loss, Take Profit, and Position Sizing
• Why Risk Management Is the Only Edge That Lasts
• How Much Should You Risk per Trade? (1%, 2%, or Less?)
• The Ultimate Risk Management Plan for Prop Firm Traders - Updated 2025
• Mastering Position Sizing: Automate or Calculate Your Risk Like a Pro
• Martingale Strategy in Trading: Compounding Power or Double-Edged Sword?
• How to Add to Winners Using Cost Averaging and Martingale Principle with Price Confirmation
• Managing Imperfect Entries in Trading - How Professionals Stay Composed

Suggested Learning Path

If you’re not sure where to start, follow this roadmap:

1. Start with Trading Psychology → Build the mindset first.
2. Move into Risk Management → Learn how to protect capital.
3. Explore Strategies & Tools → Candlesticks, Fibonacci, MAs, Indicators.
4. Apply to Assets → Gold, Indices, Forex sessions.
5. Advance to Smart Money Concepts (SMC) → Learn how institutions trade.
6. Specialize → Stop Hunts, News Trading, Turmoil Navigation.

This way, you’ll grow from foundation → application → mastery, instead of jumping around randomly.

Follow me for more daily market insights!

Jasper Osita - LinkedIn - FXStreet - YouTube

This content may have been written by a third party. ACY makes no representation or warranty and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, nor any loss arising from any investment based on a recommendation, forecast or other information supplies by any third-party. This content is information only, and does not constitute financial, investment or other advice on which you can rely.